Van has finished reading…Early One Morning by Virginia Baily

21 Oct

There’s a line Jimmy Stewart delivers in the wonderful film version of Harvey: ‘The evening wore on. That’s a very nice expression isn’t it? With your permission I’ll say it again. The evening wore on.’

I lost count of the number of times Virginia Baily produced in me the Harvey effect, where I stopped as I was reading just to savour a sentence and read it again. I’m not fond of the term beautifully written. I think it’s overused and more often than not misused. For me, with this book I think it fits. Rather than trying to ladle on the emotion, she allows the natural tension of the situation and the almost febrile state of mind of her protagonist to infect the story. Even when moving from the oppressive wartime atmosphere to the Seventies, I was never in any doubt that the threads holding Chiara’s world together could give at any moment.

The characterisation is subtle and superb. We are left to imagine for ourselves the lilt of all those Latin tongues through the scenes in the forties and all the way up to the point where conversation finally crosses the language barrier. Introducing a nuanced pattern of speech at that point works superbly, further highlighting that sense of brittleness, of fragility.  As for Daniele, it’s hard to think of another character who says so much without words and the dynamic between him and Chiara is captivating. Who do you feel for most? It would be enough I think with just these two but then Virginia gives us Maria, and just when you thought there’d be no more room, Simone too. But don’t even think of uttering the word incidental. In these characters there’s a veritable lesson in making the cast work for their place.

As for the story itself, it’s a deceptively simple premise that could be summed up in a few sentences. There’s no reliance on gimmickry or pacey action, no mind-bending plot twists to make you gasp. It’s a line of stepping stones wherein cause and effect are treated with honesty. It’s a story that could easily be true. The quietness of it, the sensitivity with which Virginia Baily presents these events gives it a confessional feel. We’re in on the secret and it’s something we mustn’t ever tell. All you need to do is take Chiara’s hand and follow.

I must express my thanks to Isabel Costello and her Literary Sofa ( – if you’ve not been you should definitely go and have a look) for arranging this copy, and to Little, Brown for sending it. There’s every likelihood this book will be in the top five I’ve read this year come December. I’ve been recommending it to anyone who’ll listen since I finished it. And I’m recommending it to you now. If it’s a thing you like to do I can say it’s also a joy to read aloud. I read it to Mrs Van. The night we finished it she even dreamt beyond the last page!

Early One Morning was published by Virago on 23rd July 2015 ISBN: 9780349006482

You can find Virginia on Twitter @VirginiaBaily


5 Responses to “Van has finished reading…Early One Morning by Virginia Baily”


  1. Van has finished reading…Life After Life by Kate Atkinson | vanisreading - 18/12/2015

    […] and yet somehow hopeful too. Like other books I’ve read on this period this year (Crooked Heart; Early One Morning) they don’t approach the war as a thing in itself, an occurrence outside of life but as what it […]

  2. Van’s top five reads in 2015 | vanisreading - 07/01/2016

    […] Second World War again in October, though in Italy rather than England. Look at the cover of Early One Morning and it gives you a good hint as to what lies inside the covers. Something quiet and a little […]

  3. Van has finished reading…Mussolini’s Island by Sarah Day | vanisreading - 01/08/2017

    […] in the memory. Not just for its period and location I’m reminded of Virginia Baily’s superb Early One Morning, and Lissa Evans’ Crooked Heart. Kate Atkinson’s Life After Life. Sarah Day’s Mussolini’s […]

  4. Van has finished reading… Yuki Means Happiness by Alison Jean Lester | vanisreading - 20/09/2017

    […] vividly in my mind. It is achingly tender. If you follow my reviews you’ll be familiar with The Harvey Effect, and Alison Jean Lester conjures it up a few times. No need for prolix or flowery effusions, she […]

  5. Van has finished reading… The Wicked Cometh by Laura Carlin | vanisreading - 03/11/2017

    […] One more. I had to beg for a tea break. The writing is really nice – a fair few moments where the Harvey effect kicked in, although our need to know what happens next kept me reading on. This one will definitely […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: